Algie Key led four Cougars in scoring with seventeen points and seven assists. Key also moved into the sixth spot on Barton's all-time scoring list with 1140 points passing Shawn Copes' 1135 point mark set during the 1989-1991 seasons and drawing to within eight points of Ebi Ere's 1148 points set during the 1999-2001 seasons. Andell Cumberbatch and Turon Parker each scored fifteen points and led the Cougar rebounding effort with eight rebounds each. Freshman Raheem Johnson followed his previous night's career high with ten points and six rebounds to go along with three blocked shots in only twenty-five minutes of play.

Kris Rolle led the Colby scoring with a double-double seventeen point fourteen rebound performance. Jeremiah Ingram scored sixteen while Terry Starks added fourteen points and eight rebounds.